Paul's Online Notes
Paul's Online Notes
Home / Calculus II / Series & Sequences / Comparison Test/Limit Comparison Test
Show Mobile Notice Show All Notes Hide All Notes
Mobile Notice
You appear to be on a device with a "narrow" screen width (i.e. you are probably on a mobile phone). Due to the nature of the mathematics on this site it is best views in landscape mode. If your device is not in landscape mode many of the equations will run off the side of your device (should be able to scroll to see them) and some of the menu items will be cut off due to the narrow screen width.

Section 4-7 : Comparison Test/Limit Comparison Test

9. Determine if the following series converges or diverges.

\[\sum\limits_{n = 1}^\infty {\frac{{4{n^2} - n}}{{{n^3} + 9}}} \]

Show All Steps Hide All Steps

Start Solution

First, the series terms are,

\[{a_n} = \frac{{4{n^2} - n}}{{{n^3} + 9}}\]

You can verify that for \(n \ge 1\) we have \(4{n^2} > n\) and so \(4{n^2} - n > 0\). Therefore, the series terms are positive and so we know that we can attempt the Comparison Test for this series.

It is very important to always check the conditions for a particular series test prior to actually using the test. One of the biggest mistakes that many students make with the series test is using a test on a series that don’t meet the conditions for the test and getting the wrong answer because of that!

Hint : Can you make a guess as to whether or not the series should converge or diverge?
Show Step 2

Let’s first see if we can make a reasonable guess as to whether this series converges or diverges.

For large enough \(n\) we know that the \({n^2}\) (a quadratic term) in the numerator will increase at a much faster rate than the \( - n\) (a linear term) portion of the numerator. Therefore the \({n^2}\) portion of the numerator will, in all likelihood, define the behavior of the numerator. Likewise, the “+9” in the denominator will not affect the size of the denominator for large \(n\) and so the terms should behave like,

\[{b_n} = \frac{{4{n^2}}}{{{n^3}}} = \frac{4}{n}\]

We also know that the series,

\[\sum\limits_{n = 1}^\infty {\frac{4}{n}} \]

will diverge because it is a harmonic series or by the \(p\)-series Test.

Therefore, it makes some sense that we can guess the series in the problem statement will probably diverge as well.

Hint : Now that we have our guess, if we’re going to use the Comparison Test, do we need to find a series with larger or a smaller terms that has the same convergence/divergence?
Show Step 3

So, because we’re guessing that the series diverge we’ll need to find a series with smaller terms that we know, or can prove, diverge.

Note as well that we’ll also need to prove that the new series terms really are smaller than the terms from the series in the problem statement. We can’t just “hope” that the will be smaller.

In this case, because the terms in the problem statement series are a rational expression, we know that we can make the series terms smaller by either making the numerator smaller or the denominator larger.

We now have a problem however. The obvious thing to try is to drop the last term in both the numerator and the denominator. Doing that however gives the following inequalities,

\[4{n^2} - n < 4{n^2}\hspace{0.5in}\hspace{0.25in}{n^3} + 9 > {n^3}\]

Using these two in the series terms gives the following relationship,

\[\frac{{4{n^2} - n}}{{{n^3} + 9}} < \frac{{4{n^2}}}{{{n^3} + 9}} < \frac{{4{n^2}}}{{{n^3}}} = \frac{4}{n}\]

Now the series,

\[\sum\limits_{n = 0}^\infty {\frac{4}{n}} \]

will definitely diverge (as discussed above) it’s terms are larger than the series terms in the problem statement. Just because a series with larger terms diverges does not, in any way, imply a series with smaller terms will also diverge!

There are other manipulations we might try but they are all liable to run into similar issues or end up with new terms that we wouldn’t be able to quickly prove convergence on.

Hint : So, if the Comparison Test won’t easily work what else is there to do?
Show Step 4

So, the Comparison Test won’t easily work in this case. That pretty much leaves the Limit Comparison Test to try. This test only requires positive terms (which we have) and a second series that we’re pretty sure behaves like the series we want to know the convergence for. Note as well that, for the Limit Comparison Test, we don’t care if the terms for the second series are larger or smaller than problem statement series terms.

If you think about it we already have exactly what we need. In Step 2 we used a second series to guess at the convergence of the problem statement series. The terms in the new series are positive (which we need) and we’re pretty sure it behaves in the same manner as the problem statement series.

So, let’s compute the limit we need for the Limit Comparison Test.

\[c = \mathop {\lim }\limits_{n \to \infty } \frac{{{a_n}}}{{{b_n}}} = \mathop {\lim }\limits_{n \to \infty } \left[ {{a_n}\frac{1}{{{b_n}}}} \right] = \mathop {\lim }\limits_{n \to \infty } \left[ {\frac{{4{n^2} - n}}{{{n^3} + 9}}\,\,\frac{n}{4}} \right] = \mathop {\lim }\limits_{n \to \infty } \left[ {\frac{{4{n^3} - {n^2}}}{{4{n^3} + 36}}\,} \right] = 1\] Show Step 5

Okay. We now have \(0 < c = 1 < \infty \), i.e. \(c\) is not zero or infinity and so by the Limit Comparison Test the two series must have the same convergence. We determined in Step 2 that the second series diverges and so the series given in the problem statement must also diverge.

Be careful with the Comparison Test. Too often students just try to “force” larger or smaller by just hoping that the second series terms has the correct relationship (i.e. larger or smaller as needed) to the problem series terms. The problem is that this often leads to an incorrect answer. Be careful to always prove the larger/smaller nature of the series terms and if you can’t get a series term of the correct larger/smaller nature then you may need to resort to the Limit Comparison Test.